We don’t advocate minimalism; instead, our practical philosophy is aimed at: creating peace of mind; making space for people and experiences; doing good for others and the environment. Our definition of the state of clutter is therefore subjective – it is when someone owns things beyond their threshold of comfort. We call that state ‘when stuff owns you’.
We contrast our approach with that of the minimalist movement. Minimalism, in this context, is usually defined as a deliberate attempt to live with less. Living with less, preferably as little as possible, is a specific objective. That's not an ideal starting point for our philosophy of living organised and clutter-free. We've seen clients with a lot of stuff, well-curated, beautifully stored, displayed and used, who are comfortable in their own skins and not stressed by all that. Similarly, we see many clients who don't have a lot, by the average standard, yet they feel that their lives are filled with too much stuff.
Our definition of what constitutes clutter therefore aims to draw a pragmatic squiggle that will be different for each person at any point in time.
A note on points in time - we notice that people tend to accumulate things until their children leave home, or, if childless, until they retire, or until another impactful life event causes their life trajectory to change. Such an event could be anything, expected or unexpected, that has a significant impact. We regularly see the following examples: illness, losing a loved one or even a favourite pet, divorce, children leaving home, retirement, moving or emigrating.
Storytime - A modern Ms Havisham
An elderly client, who lived alone in a peri-urban fashionably horsey area was brutally attacked in her home, but survived and insisted on staying there, surrounded by a life-time of memories. She appeared to be a classical hoarder and, when subjected to this terrible trauma, it tipped her over the edge. She was probably suffering from Miss Havisham syndrome - from the famous character in Charles’ Dickens’ Great Expectations - also known as disposophobia or senile squalor syndrome.
Before the attack, she suffered a number of traumatic life events, going through a divorce, losing her job, and she responded poorly to her adult daughter leaving home.
Our client’s books were all filed alphabetically, up until the year her daughter left home - all books purchased after that were piled willy-nilly. We also found a jar of tonsils (the daughter’s) by her bed-side table.
Classic Miss Havisham syndrome is about hoarding pets - Our client owned twenty-four Daschunds. The paperwork and filing related to the pets was impeccable: all toenail clippings were filed chronologically and alphabetically.
Paranoia is associated with the syndrome: Our client was convinced that there was money hidden in her library of books, and so we had to flip through every book to check for money before donating the books to charity. We did not find a cent.
Only intervention, initiated by the daughter, and an extremely sensitive approach convinced her to allow us to clean up, help her downsize and move somewhere safe.
Our client never admitted that she had a problem. Even on the last day, when she came back to see the cleared-out house, she sat crying on a chair in the kitchen, saying she wanted to come back to her house because it was her dream to die there.
So despite our best intentions, it ended traumatically for her and I started going to counselling regularly and still do occasionally, to debrief my own feelings about these kinds of situations.
We define clutter as that collection of stuff that no-one in your household uses or otherwise benefits from and that causes you or, someone in your household, some (not insignificant) stress.
This definition seems simple but is a mouthful, and we'll discuss our significant insights.
- Clutter can be digital: A music collection that is not well-curated and, when set to shuffle causes you more frustration than joy, is an excellent example of potential digital clutter. A digital filing system that doesn't enable you to lay your hands on an important document when you need, is another. You may have to curate or organise better. Fortunately, this problem is increasingly solved for us by technology companies. For instance, they create intelligent playlists out of your observed preferences. They similarly embed powerful search engines into their applications so that, provided that you know how to use these tools, you can find your needle in your haystack in split seconds. Online storage solutions and services are becoming increasingly powerful, and are free or affordable.
- Clutter can be paper or task related: It can be an accumulation of admin tasks, paperwork or bills to pay, that cause you consternation.
- Compromise: An important implication of our definition is the principle of compromise that is required in any household. One person's clutter may be another's security blanket. There is no right or wrong here, nor is there a magic wand. Suffice it to say, it would be best if you could reach a compromise with your roommates.
- Focus on the bigger picture: You have to weigh the harm, usually stress or frustration, against the benefit, and you and your roomies (if any) have to judge an ideal outcome. In evaluating conflicting interests, try and work out if the clutter stress that you and your roomie is feeling is a minor irritation or a big deal. We like to talk about Zenning (not sweating) the small stuff. Adopting this attitude towards potential clutter is a good habit that benefits all relationships, including the one that you have with yourself. From the above discussion, we can see that the benefit may be, and often is, emotional.
- Regret: It would be ideal if you also weighed current clutter-induced stress against potential future regret. For instance, what would you do if, a week after throwing that useless gadget out, you realise that it is an essential component of a thing that you haven't used in a while, but now need? This example gives us one good reason why decluttering and organising your stuff go together. Nevertheless, even when you’ve thought about this clearly, it would be prudent to expect some regret and to distinguish, in your planning, between emotional regret (you sold granny’s copper pot which you weren’t using and now your sister wants it) and practical regret (you purged a charging cable that you now need.) It is also easy to overestimate this problem.
- Longevity : Clothes aside (we’ll come back to this category), if you have not used something for a significant amount of time, you’re not likely to need that thing in the future. Keep in mind that the time-frame will vary per item - is it something that you use regularly, or only in particular seasons, or only when you’re on holiday? In this context, the past is an excellent predictor of the future.
Storytime - Do you have the time?
One of our clients had a watch collection. We noticed that he only wore a smart watch, and that he was an active user of its (wellness and convenience) functionality. We pried a little and he acknowledged that he wasn’t likely ever to wear his watches again. We helped him choose the watch that was most meaningful to him to keep – it was an heirloom - and then sent the rest of the collection to a specialist auctioneer, where he got fair value for it.
This is an example of how people outgrow their collections, and move on. Our client never looked back.
- Fashion and décor: When evaluating whether you’re likely to want to use something in a fashion category again (clothes; décor), ask yourself whether it is a classical and timeless, or a fad, item. Experts and online resources can help you judge this. We will come back to the idea that it helps to identify or develop your own style, because then you can more easily avoid being the victim of fashion cycles. Judge carefully whether you want to keep clothes of different sizes because you have a tendency to gain and lose weight.
- Bringing joy to others : A source of discomfort that we'd like to add to your emotional equilibrium is the joy of others, when owning your unused stuff. So let's say you have a well-organised drawer of unused electronics that doesn't bother you in the least. Somewhere in your circle of influence there is a person who can use it, instead of allowing it to become obsolete. It is also kinder to the environment to ensure the maximum use out of something before recycling it.
In summary, our definition of clutter is more than a definition, it is a practical philosophy of how to live your best life. In general, win-win opportunities are rare. In our humble view, this is an easy one to bag.
In the next instalment of the So Sorted story, we take a look at how to approach a declutter project.